PENDING: 4849 Central Ave -Meridian Kessler

Offered at $875,000

Legendary 4849 Central Ave could be yours!

This beautifully renovated 1880s farmhouse is believed to be one of the oldest homes in Meridian-Kessler, possibly built by a member of the Oliver Johnson family. Rich in history and filled with original craftsmanship, this home is a rare gem that blends old-world charm with thoughtful modern updates.

Situated just blocks from locally owned coffee shops, restaurants, and all the conveniences of 49th & Penn, you'll love being part of this highly coveted Midtown Indianapolis neighborhood, known for its unique architecture, mature trees, sidewalks, and bike lanes.

While much of the 1880s character remains, the home has been updated with newer plumbing and electrical systems. Most of the original plaster and lathe walls have been replaced with drywall for improved comfort and efficiency.

The updated kitchen is a true standout—featuring a massive island perfect for entertaining, sustainable marmoleum flooring, an enviable walk-in pantry, and seamless flow to a charming courtyard patio.

This home offers multiple inviting spaces to gather and relax—from the generous living room that opens to a sunroom, to the cozy den with the original fireplace, or the elegant formal dining room.

Upstairs, you'll find four spacious bedrooms, all with ample closet space. The hallway bathroom includes both a tub and shower, plus convenient second-floor laundry. The primary suite features a private bath with a walk-in shower, heated floors, natural stone tile, extra storage, and a surprisingly generous walk-in closet for a home of this era.

Don’t miss the massive third-floor playroom and the oversized garage, perfect for extra storage or hobbies.

All of this sits on a rare double lot in a prime location. From the moment you walk through the front door, you'll notice the richness of the hardwood floors, custom details like coffered ceilings, and a tasteful nod to Craftsman style—all paired with the comfort and reliability of modern construction methods.

4849 Central Ave is the perfect blend of timeless character and contemporary living.

Updates and Features of note: Plumbing, electrical, windows, basement sump pump installed and much of the plaster and lathe were replaced when the home was renovated before the current owner purchased the property in 2012. HVAC + AC replaced in 2019, Kitchen renovated in 2016 and features marmoleum sustainable flooring, quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances. Surround sound in Living, Dinning Room and Den. Primary bath has heated tile floors. Seller believes third floor has been plumbed for an additional bath or kitchenette. Garage was built in 2016 with ample storage and an 8ft garage door. Whole house water purifier and water softener replaced in 2018.

All of this plus the retained craftsmanship of the 1880’s and the walkability of Meridian Kessler!

Showings start April 11th.

〰️

〰️